Skip to content Accessibility Notice Statement
Loading...
loading gif
Hello, Guest
  • Trending
  • Bestsellers
  • New Releases
  • Movers & Shakers
  • Shop
  • Featured Sales Featured Sales
  • Fruit Fruit
  • Vegetables Vegetables
  • Eggs Eggs
  • See More
  • Meat Meat
    • Meat
    • All Products
    • Meat - PreOrder Meat - PreOrder
      • Meat - PreOrder
      • All Products
      • Beef - PreOrder Beef - PreOrder
      • Lamb - PreOrder Lamb - PreOrder
      • Pork - PreOrder Pork - PreOrder
      • See Less
    • Lamb Lamb
    • Broth Broth
    • Beef Beef
    • See More
    • Poultry Poultry
    • Pork Pork
    • See Less
  • Dairy Dairy
    • Dairy
    • All Products
    • Cheese Cheese
    • Yogurt Yogurt
    • Butter Butter
    • Ice Cream Ice Cream
    • See Less
  • Grocery Grocery
    • Grocery
    • All Products
    • Misc Misc
    • Refrigerated Refrigerated
    • Honey and Syrup Honey and Syrup
    • Jams Jams
    • See More
    • Nut butters Nut butters
    • Vinegars Vinegars
    • Oils Oils
    • Frozen Frozen
    • See Less
  • Beans-Grains-Lentils Beans-Grains-Lentils
  • Beverages Beverages
    • Beverages
    • All Products
    • Coffee Coffee
    • Kombucha Kombucha
    • Tea Tea
    • Sweetened Bevs Sweetened Bevs
    • Juice Juice
    • See Less
  • Bread Bread
  • Snacks and Bars Snacks and Bars
    • Snacks and Bars
    • All Products
    • Bars Bars
    • Meat Sticks & Jerky Meat Sticks & Jerky
    • Fresh & Local Snacks Fresh & Local Snacks
    • Snacks Snacks
    • See Less
  • Nuts Nuts
  • Herbs & Spices Herbs & Spices
  • Mushrooms Mushrooms
  • Gifts & Gift Certificates Gifts & Gift Certificates
  • Wholesale Wholesale
    • Wholesale
    • All Products
    • Wholesale Fruit Wholesale Fruit
    • Wholesale Vegetable Wholesale Vegetable
    • Wholesale Other Wholesale Other
    • See Less
  • See Less
  • Learn More
  • About Us
  • What They Say
  • Using Our Service
  • Why Choose Us
  • See More
  • Pick-up locations
  • Our Farms
  • Delivery Area
  • Boxes
  • Jobs
  • See Less
  • Help & Settings
  • Sign Up Today!
  • Get Help
  • Login







Sign Up Now & Take 10% Off Your First Order Using Promo Code: GOOD4ME SIGN UP NOW!
Prudent Produce Prudent Produce
How it Works Shop Recipes FAQ Contact Sign Up! Log In
Log In

Login via email:
  • Shop Home /
  • Dairy /
  • Cheese

Cheddar Old Style Reserve Cheese

Milton Creamery
Cheddar Old Style Reserve Cheese Main Image

Cheddar Old Style Reserve Cheese

Milton Creamery
$8.50
Unit: package approx 8oz
sold out!

  • Description

Description

We've taken our basic cheddar and aged it longer, giving it a strong medium cheddar bite that will fulfill any cheddar connoisseurs' need.

Ingredients:

Pasteurized Cow's Milk, Salt, Veg. Rennet, Cultures.


Share with friends!

More Best Sellers from Cheese
3 Cheese Mexican, Shredded 3 Cheese Mexican, Shredded 6 oz
Organic Valley
3 Cheese Mexican, Shredded, 6 oz
$5.99
A2-A2 Heritage Cheddar Cheese A2-A2 Heritage Cheddar Cheese 8 oz
Kalona
A2-A2 Heritage Cheddar Cheese, 8 oz
$6.25
A2-A2 Raw Milk OPE! Cheddar Cheese A2-A2 Raw Milk OPE! Cheddar Cheese 8 oz
Kalona
A2-A2 Raw Milk OPE! Cheddar Cheese, 8 oz
$6.25
Cheddar, Caramelized Onion Cheddar, Caramelized Onion package approx 8oz
only 2 left!
Milton Creamery
Cheddar, Caramelized Onion, package approx 8oz
Local- This is a local product!Farm Fresh- Straight from the farm to youFarm Fresh- Premium Quality!!
$7.50
Cheddar, Shredded, OV, Thick cut Cheddar, Shredded, OV, Thick cut 6 oz
Organic Valley
Cheddar, Shredded, OV, Thick cut, 6 oz
USDA Organic- USDA Certified Organic
$5.99
Mozzarella, Shredded, AE Mozzarella, Shredded, AE 8 oz
Andrew and Everett
Mozzarella, Shredded, AE, 8 oz
$4.49
sold out!
Mozzarella, Shredded, OV Mozzarella, Shredded, OV 6 oz
Organic Valley
Mozzarella, Shredded, OV, 6 oz
USDA Organic- USDA Certified Organic
$5.99
Natural White Cheddar Cheese Curds 5 oz Natural White Cheddar Cheese Curds 5 oz 5 oz
Ellsworth Cooperative
Natural White Cheddar Cheese Curds 5 oz
$2.49
Parmesan Block Parmesan Block 8oz
Parmesan Block, 8oz
$4.50
Parmesan, Grated Parmesan, Grated 2.82oz cup
Parmesan, Grated, 2.82oz cup
$6.61
Swiss Cheese, Slices Swiss Cheese, Slices 6 oz
Organic Valley
Swiss Cheese, Slices, 6 oz
$6.99
Cheese Curds, White Cheddar Cheese Curds, White Cheddar 8 oz
Pickett Fence Creamery
Cheese Curds, White Cheddar, 8 oz
Local- This is a local product!Farm Fresh- Straight from the farm to youFarm Fresh- Premium Quality!!
$6.25
sold out!
Prairie Breeze Cheese Prairie Breeze Cheese package approx 8oz
Milton Creamery
Prairie Breeze Cheese, package approx 8oz
Local- This is a local product!
$9.49
sold out!
Panir Panir each
only 2 left!
Radiance Dairy
Panir, each
Local- This is a local product!
$5.99
Black Pepper Cheddar Cheese Black Pepper Cheddar Cheese package approx 8oz
only 1 left!
Milton Creamery
Black Pepper Cheddar Cheese, package approx 8oz
Local- This is a local product!Farm Fresh- Straight from the farm to youFarm Fresh- Premium Quality!!
$7.50
Mild Cheddar Cheese Mild Cheddar Cheese 16 oz
only 1 left!
WW Homestead Dairy
Mild Cheddar Cheese, 16 oz
Local- This is a local product!
$10.99
View More

Shop

Shop Past Orders

Home

My Order

Account
Quick Links
Home
About Us
Your Account
Contact Us
Gift Certificates
Top 5 Reasons
Where We Deliver
How Our Service Works
Privacy & Terms of Service
Accessibility Notice Statement
Do Not Sell My Personal Information
Get the Apps!
App Store Get it on Google Play

Gifts
Gift Certificates
Send a Gift Box



We Love Local
Are you a local artisan or farmer? Get in Touch!

Prudent Produce
515-367-0302
[email protected]
 www.prudentproduce.net/

12806 NE 64th Street
Elkhart, IA 50073

Powered by Stripe Payments
Produce Delivery Software by Kiva Logic
iPhone is a trademark of Apple Inc., registered in the U.S. and other countries. App Store is a service mark of Apple Inc. Android is a trademark of Google Inc.
© Copyright 2025 Prudent Produce. All Rights Reserved. 12806 NE 64th Street, Elkhart, IA 50073


/* add this to the default css: .shopbtnholder{ display: none; } */ ?>
Loading